2008 Woodie Awards
Hearings End, Alito Expected to be Confirmed
James Kuhnhenn and Stephen Henderson
Issue date: 1/16/06 Section: News
- Page 1 of 2 next >
Samuel Alito ended his testimony before the Senate Judiciary Committee Thursday amid a sense that Democrats are resigned to the fact that the conservative jurist will become a member of the Supreme Court.
The hearings continued with testimony from seven current and former appellate court judges from Alito's circuit, an unprecedented event that provoked comments from Democrats and others about the propriety of judges being involved in the political nomination process.
Democrats were considering whether to seek a delay in the committee's vote Tuesday on Alito, a decision that could signal whether they will attempt to block the nomination.
Alito appeared to have solid support from Republicans. Many Alito backers were hoping to win enough Democratic votes to push his support above 60 votes. There are 55 Republicans in the Senate, 44 Democrats and one independent who tends to vote Democratic.
Grilled by Democrats on issues ranging from abortion to his integrity, Alito emerged without significant damage after four days as a sworn witness.
"I'd be the same sort of justice in the Supreme Court as I've been a judge on the court of appeals," said Alito, a 15-year veteran of the 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals. "If anybody looks at my record on the court of appeals, they can get an idea about the way I approach the work of being a judge. And that's what I would try to do on the Supreme Court."
It was that record that came under much scrutiny during his testimony, with Republicans portraying it as that of a mainstream conservative and Democrats arguing that it signaled an ideological predisposition that could change the balance of the Supreme Court.
"The evidence before us makes it very hard to vote yes on your nomination," said Sen. Charles Schumer, D-N.Y. "While you give the appearance of being a meticulous legal navigator, in the end, you almost always choose the rightward course."
But with few other senators in Washington other than Judiciary Committee members, it was difficult to determine whether Democratic opposition was deep-seated enough to make Alito's confirmation vote the closest since Clarence Thomas was confirmed 52-48 in 1991.
The hearings continued with testimony from seven current and former appellate court judges from Alito's circuit, an unprecedented event that provoked comments from Democrats and others about the propriety of judges being involved in the political nomination process.
Democrats were considering whether to seek a delay in the committee's vote Tuesday on Alito, a decision that could signal whether they will attempt to block the nomination.
Alito appeared to have solid support from Republicans. Many Alito backers were hoping to win enough Democratic votes to push his support above 60 votes. There are 55 Republicans in the Senate, 44 Democrats and one independent who tends to vote Democratic.
Grilled by Democrats on issues ranging from abortion to his integrity, Alito emerged without significant damage after four days as a sworn witness.
"I'd be the same sort of justice in the Supreme Court as I've been a judge on the court of appeals," said Alito, a 15-year veteran of the 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals. "If anybody looks at my record on the court of appeals, they can get an idea about the way I approach the work of being a judge. And that's what I would try to do on the Supreme Court."
It was that record that came under much scrutiny during his testimony, with Republicans portraying it as that of a mainstream conservative and Democrats arguing that it signaled an ideological predisposition that could change the balance of the Supreme Court.
"The evidence before us makes it very hard to vote yes on your nomination," said Sen. Charles Schumer, D-N.Y. "While you give the appearance of being a meticulous legal navigator, in the end, you almost always choose the rightward course."
But with few other senators in Washington other than Judiciary Committee members, it was difficult to determine whether Democratic opposition was deep-seated enough to make Alito's confirmation vote the closest since Clarence Thomas was confirmed 52-48 in 1991.